A personal view
Can we unlock Ivory-tower gate?
I sometimes get the feeling that some educators move into places like the web and virtual worlds in order to keep the lock on the gate or keep “control” of the world of learning – in other words keep the learning behind the ivory-tower gate – in a universe which is expanding learning opportunities exponentially outside the normal education system.
Google Search and the wikipedia system, as unreliable as the data they dredge up or record sometimes is, has made information available to (initially) anyone who writes/reads English, and has access to a phoneline and a computer; almost any old computer. For many the advent of the web as we know it today has made the ivory tower virtually irrelevant for true learning.
Communities of interest/barriers which tertiary institutions thrive on – and which I once thought were the reason for universities: where else could one easily meet girls with the same interests who were away from home and available? – have given way in many cases to web-based social networks, which today are more pervasive and often more tribal than fraternities or sororities. The ivory-tower communities of interest also encompass the professional groups which have grown out of tertiary institutions to ensure the closed-shop enclave nature of some intellectual/professional pursuits and thus increase the workplace value of a tertiary education.(eg law and medicine).
But the barriers, which started to break down in the 1960s with the call for the establishment of “free” universities without examinations or structured courses, or in some cases attendance – even though re-erected by academics wanting to protect their patches – are threatened with complete demolition by the web with its virtually-free, anytime, anywhere knowledge and/or propaganda.
Today anyone who can read and write can educate themselves, given the will, the discipline, a computer and a web link. But they still can’t get the piece of paper that would allow them to be recognised as a “practitioner”: Medical associations and other groups, created alongside the English-speaking ivory-tower system, do all they can to keep the foreign-language/university educated, self-educated and non ivory-tower educated hoi polloi out, citing lower education standards in the university/country of origin/culture differences, or non-recognised credentials.
I had hoped – and this is a personal, non-academic view – that there was a new force/ideas afoot with the Edupunk movement in the US, but alas I think I might have been mistaken and what is happening in SLENZ might be closer to the future, where the whole process of the creation of the SLENZ project has appeared to have been democratised, transparent and allowing input, albeit guided, from all. It is also in many ways directed at adults who the ivory-tower system has often conveniently bypassed.
I feel that even some of those in the edupunk movement [The revolution will be syndicated (http://blip.tv/file/1441388/)], in proclaiming their attempts to break the ivory-tower barriers and break out of what they see as the stifling, red-tape ridden, zombified (LMS) systems are doing little more than trying to preserve their academic power by taking the nuts and bolts off campus, while hypocritically still keeping their roles as paid academics within their institutions. Their middle-class methods may work in a society where computers and broadband gigabytes off-campus are virtually free, but in fact, also serve to alienate those who are the true revolutionaries in education and elsewhere, who are working completely (and often anarchically) outside the ivory-tower system, like many of the bloggers on the web. The edupunk movement, also like many of today’s great, well-washed, middle-class don’t seem to understand that Che Guevara was a “real revolutionary” who got down and dirty, not just a model for a tee-shirt logo.
To me the edupunk attack on zombie systems in Ivory-tower education reeks of the faddish criticism which often surrounds Bill Gates and the Microsoft Windows operating system. They both “suck” but if it wasn’t for the Ivory Tower system we wouldn’t have academics who could freely attack it by biting the hand that feeds them, and if it wasn’t for the ubiquitous Windows system we might not have the cheap PCs and the Web as we know it today.
Although, like PhD candidate and VW researcher, Sara Robbins-Bell (SL: Intellagirl Tully), I would be loath to have a doctor who had trained and graduated only in SL, or done his study through blogs, perform surgery on me, I still think there is space for a much wider appreciation of the learning choices and desires of the students outside the ivory-tower system; learning through peers and users, even bloggers, rather than academics. No longer can we view learning in this way as second class to piece of paper with “graduate” on it.
The problem, however, for the self/web-educated woman/man is how to ascribe a recognised/accepted, standard measure to one’s capabilities in order to secure one’s first, paid employment. After that, of course, one should be able to secure employment on the basis of work experience and references.
These thoughts on where education is going and the on-going need to develop critical literacy in the learning population in general, if we are going to benefit as much as we should from the educational possibilities of the web in all its forms, were brought to mind by two blogged articles and videos which I am grateful that academics Leigh Blackall (SL: Leroy Goalpost) and Dr Scott Diener (SL: Professor Noarlunga) pointed me too.
Although long (54 minutes and 55 minutes) they will reward you by giving you an inside view on where web-based education in 21st Century US could be going. The first, a streaming and streamed video presentation at the New Media Consortium, suffers from 15 minutes or so of old-hat waffle posing as SL theatre which is fairly old hat, while in the second, Sara Robbins-Bell, starts well on where education is going for the millennials but then fudges the issue with her solutions, which I personally felt were more about keeping academics in control than in actual learning for students. Her reference to the on-going need for critical literacy education hit a nerve though.
Leigh, a SLENZ “learning designer”and educational developer with Otago Polytechnic, said, for him, the significance of “zombies, edtech survival and edupunk ” ["The revolution will be syndicated" [(http://blip.tv/file/1441388/)] was:
- Innovative approach to live presentation in the education technology sector.
- Primary content was developed outside SL and so an example of reusability and accessibility.
- Use of a Zombie Flaming theme as an ice breaker in a live presentation in SL.
- Zombies as a kind of homage to some SL pop culture and griefing fun.
- Streaming Blip.tv videos into SL.
- Generation of Machinima from the presentation (more accessibility and reusability).
- Inspired after event edtech blogging interests.
For another report on the presentation go to http://cogdogblog.com/2008/11/07/revolution-is-syndicated/
Meanwhile Diener, [http://scottdiener.edublogs.org/], who has created the the Long White Cloud island in SL (Long White Cloud/31/38/27) for Auckland University, returned from the Educause 2008 conference, “overwhelmed with the sheer bulk of information I encountered. “
Describing Sarah Robbins-Bill presentation, “Social Media and Education: The Conflict Between Technology and Institutional Education, and the Future” ( http://hosted.mediasite.com/hosted5/Viewer/?peid=5eb9cd4798a4488288e0b6d117f5c99c) as a highlight he said she presented “a quite challenging picture of the future of higher education in an era of rapidly expanding, free, and leveraged technologies” before “highly” recommending that one should view it. Some of you may have seen it in the Educause 2008 link files posted previously, but you haven’t it is well worth the time spent with it.
In his blog Scott also recommended a new online 2.1MB book, “The Tower and the Cloud – Higher Education in the Age of Cloud Computing,” edited by Richard Katz. Click on book cover.
Filed under: Education in virtual worlds | Tagged: "The Tower in the Cloud - Higher education in the age o, Auckland University, Blackall, blip.tv, cogdogblog, Diener, Educause, edupunk, Intellagirl Tully, New Media consortium, Otago Polyytechic, Richard katz, Robbins-Bell, slenz | 4 Comments »